OM-Ant

Effort, Output, Outcomes: Three Currencies in One Room

Share this article

Somebody on your team is working very hard right now and quietly expecting that to count for something.

Somebody else is shipping a lot and assuming the volume speaks for itself.

And the organisation above both of them says, in its strategy documents and its town halls, that what it really cares about is impact.

Three different currencies. One room. Nobody has said out loud which one is actually being paid.

That is where most of the confusion about performance comes from, and almost nobody names it.


The three things

  • Effort is what you put in. Hours, attention, difficulty absorbed, the weekend you did not take. It is entirely yours. You control it completely.
  • Output is what you produced. The campaign that ran, the feature that shipped, the report that was delivered. You mostly control it. Other people and circumstances get a say, but not a large one.
  • Outcomes are what changed because of it. Revenue, adoption, retention, a customer who stayed. You influence these. You do not control them.

Notice the pattern. As you move from the first to the third, the value rises, and your control falls.

That gap is not a design flaw. It is the whole problem.


Why we reach for effort

Effort is the only one of the three that feels like anything from the inside.

You can feel a hard week. You cannot feel a retention improvement. Outcomes arrive late, quietly, often filtered through a dashboard someone else reads, sometimes months after you stopped thinking about the work.

So when someone questions our performance, effort is what we reach for, because it is the only evidence we have direct access to. I worked late. I took it on when nobody else would. I have been carrying this for months.

All of that is usually true. None of it is what you are being paid for.

This is also why effort is such a comfortable place to live. The feeling of working hard is available on demand. The feeling of having changed something is not, and it depends on things outside you.


Why organisations pay for output

Here is where it gets dishonest, and mostly not on purpose.

Nearly every organisation states that it rewards outcomes. Almost every one of them actually rewards output, for a simple reason. Output is visible on the timescale that promotions and reviews run on.

Outcomes take quarters. Sometimes years. A review happens in March. So what gets noticed is the volume of visible work in the window, and the person who shipped eleven things reads as stronger than the person who shipped two.

Yes! Even when one of those two mattered more than all eleven. Hmm!

That is how you end up with the review that confuses someone. They worked hard, which they expected to count. They shipped a lot, which they expected to count. And they are being assessed against something nobody mentioned.


The part that is genuinely difficult

I want to be fair to the outcome side, because the honest objection is real.

Outcomes carry luck. The campaign that worked had a tailwind. The launch that failed hit a market shift nobody saw. Judge purely on outcomes, and you reward weather, punish bad timing, and teach people to avoid anything uncertain.

So “just measure outcomes” is not the clean answer it sounds like.

But the solution is not to retreat to effort. It is to be specific about which one you are using and why, for this role, in this period.

Some roles are genuinely output roles. Volume and consistency are the job. Say so, and stop pretending otherwise in the review.

Some roles are outcome roles, where two good decisions a year beat two hundred tasks. Say that too, and then do not quietly count the tasks.

And effort belongs in exactly one place: it is how you judge someone when the outcome went badly for reasons outside their control. Not as a reward, but as context. Did they do the right things with what they had? That is a fair question, and it is almost never asked.


What this means in practice

If you lead people, name the currency before the period starts, not during the review. The review is too late. By then the person has already spent a year optimising for the wrong thing in good faith.

If you are being managed, ask. Most people never do, because it feels like a strange question. It is not. “When we get to March, what will you actually be looking at?” is a reasonable thing to want to know in advance.

And for yourself, the uncomfortable check is this. If someone asked what changed because of your last year of work, could you answer without listing activity?

I personally have had years where I could not. Not because the year was wasted, but because I had been measuring myself in the currency that felt best rather than the one that counted.


Three currencies in one room, and nobody declares the exchange rate.

The hard worker thinks effort should count. The producer thinks volume should count. The organisation says impact counts and pays for visible activity anyway.

Everyone is being sincere. Everyone is using a different unit.

Most of what people experience as unfair treatment at work is just an unnamed exchange rate.

Let's discuss how my leadership can drive your next strategic initiative